Lyle’s rewritten half dozen verse text is roughly synchronous to your songster text shortly after removal of your own last verse of your latter. Lyle’s rewritten variation, but not, has the regiment going to Kilkenny, in place of Killarney. Lyle’s tune was “The fresh Bonnie Bluish Forget about-Me-Maybe not,” which was considering inside the R. An effective. Smith’s The latest Irish Minstrel , letter.d. [1825, the initial, supposedly pent up, edition]. New identity of one’s song could there be given because “New Housemaid out-of Derby.” While Lyle’s text “Pretty Peg out-of Derby” is actually meaningless due to the fact a timeless tune, we are able to make sure “Pretty Peggy regarding Derby” was sung into the Scotland in the 1st quarter of one’s 19th century that have a text much like you to definitely regarding songster. [Incongrously, Lyle’s text message instead of a beneficial chapbook otherwise broadside content appears Roy Palmer’s current Everyman’s Publication off Ballads. ]

Cahusac inside 1788, and you will one layer song that have sounds is actually two Western choices, “Peggy out-of Darby”, and this commences “You will find good gay Captain from inside the Darby City”

Perhaps some prior to “Quite Peggy away from Derby, O” try rewritten due to the fact “The Bonnie Lass o’ Fyvie” because confirmed by a copy in the Peter Buchan’s MSS regarding United kingdom Library, which happen to be believed to big date about 1828.

The original line and a half, almost like people a lot more than, are during the an excellent medley within the Vol. We, p. 4, 1825. You can find musical towards the tune “Fairly Peggy out-of Derby, O” for the p. 107 and you may 276 away from Vol. III, 1828, and also the first line of “Peggy out of Darby” is during a medley towards the p. 284.

Lyle plus typed a new tune on track, provided regarding works cited, and you may posted prior to which have music

T. Crofton Crocker on Popular Sounds off Ireland , London area, 1839, p. 124 (p. 121 off 1886 reprint), claims, “The newest very Housemaid from Derby, O!” is proven to be producing an Irishman, however, end up being will bring no particulars whatever, not really bringing-up where a duplicate of the text or tune could well be discover. It seems that Crocker expected his subscribers become familiar towards track and tune. The data cited above generally seems to us to end up being quite conclusive when deciding to take “Fairly Peggy away from Derby” to-be an Irish tune and you may track. Devoid of this evidence, but not, there were counterclaims. Wm. Chappell inside the New music of your bГ¤sta utlГ¤ndska kvinnor fГ¶r amerikanska mГ¤n Olden Go out , II, p. 771, detailed Crocker’s claim, however, intended your track wasn’t Irish, although not, he offered zero lead facts. Chappell’s statement you to definitely Bunting refused it is versus foundation. Bunting didn’t discuss the brand new tune, that is most certainly not the same as stating the guy declined it. Donnal O’Sullivan, concurs with Chappell inside the post on Irish Folk music inside the latest fifth ed. from Grove’s Dictionary , however, alludes to zero facts pro otherwise con, therefore we don’t know just what research he’d viewed, or no.

Lastly, a couple items I haven’t yet seen. There’s a copy of the pay attention an excellent flute teacher authored by T. BUCEM lists no content from the throughout the United kingdom Countries.

Unrelated: “Falls out of Brandy” are a significantly more mature unrelated song from equivalent title, also known as “Dribbles off Brandy.” The latter identity Thomson’s tune to the listen his Edinburgh ballad opera ‘The Disturb Gallant’, 1738. A couple of years after so it tune was copied into the NLS MS 6299. This new track you will pass on the amazing that towards the tune when we failed to be aware that the latest tune is actually prior to. “The brand new Dandy, O,” Thomas Moore’s track to own their song “Younger Can get Moon” in 5th number of Irish Melodies , letter.d. is a separate tune in six/8 day which have the same term, plainly given by Moore from the chorus regarding a song within the Robin Hood the spot where the track checked versus name.